Nonna Marie's Gelato & Coffee Bar

Customer service was great, and the gelato itself was fine. However, the prices are not posted. Probably because they are WAY over priced. If you pressure a customer into getting a topping you should tell them its an upcharge. If one gelato flavor is more expensive than the rest, TELL THE CUSTOMER! We left feeling absolutely robbed. $5 for a tiny cup of sorbetto is ridiculous. And $8.75 for 2 small scoops? Seriously? There would be no issues if the prices were posted and customers were informed of upcharges. In fact, if the prices were posted, we would not have wasted our money here. Also, we understand that its due to the quality and it being homeade but to not have prices posted is unfair.

Wonderful homemade gelato and variety of flavors. The flavored waffle cones were the cherry on top it was lovely. Run by kind family, excellent service!

Hand-made gelato, family run atmosphere, very friendly service. My favorite is the Cognac Sea Salt Caramel. Definitely worth the trip and an adult flavor.

Best Gelato on the island! 🍨 Especially the “Depp’s mega pint” 😂😂 #justiceforjohnny

We loved everything about this place! The shop was very clean, inviting, and esthetically pleasing. The employees were nice and the gelato was amazing! Loved the flavored homemade waffle cones.

We made it to Nonna Marie’s tonight and I had the best gelato I have ever tasted in the US. Family owned and operated and the husband makes the gelato and the wife bakes the other good including flavored waffle cones. Do yourself a favor and visit. Some flavors are made with real alcohol and it is a perfect combination. I had the Puna Colada gelato mixed with Lemon gelato. Amazing. My son had peach. We’ll be back!

What a great family-owned gelato store. They have a wide variety of great tasting gelato and lots of cone and dish options. During my last visit I'm at three members of the family and they are such a pleasure to talk with. Service was excellent. The place is clean and the seating is fun too.

The most friendliest service with The best gelato ever ! Literally been 2 times this week !!

This family owned business is amazing! The sweetest family and best gelato around!!

So good! Best gelato outside of Italy I’ve had.