Belmar Bakery

My nephew was wanting something sweet, so naturally, we went into the bakery to satisfy his sweet tooth. He was not disappointed in his decision to purchase a slice of their strawberry cake. When he took his first bite, his words were "OMG! This is the best strawberry cake EVER". This young man is no stranger to quality baked goods, he is 20 years old and rarely eats sweets, but when he does, only belmar is able to satisfy his cravings.

I had a pretty challenging request for my grooms cake. Not only did they meet my expectations but they went over the top. Such great attention to detail and amazing customer service. On top of that the brides cake was everything she wanted and then some. 10/10 would recommend

They did a phenomenal job on my sons cookies for his birthday. I even ordered them last minute, and they were able to complete the order. I come here often for their cookies. We love this place, it is worth a visit

Bought a chocolate cream pie and there was a thin coat of chocolate filling and the rest was whipped cream! I’ve bought a lot of these pies through the years and they were great but this one was NOT!! Very disappointed in the tiny amount of chocolate filling in it!! Plus it was for a birthday and it was embarrassing!

We stopped in early AM to pick out some things for a birthday gift. We found some tasty macaroons, some colorful artisan jellies and the service and attention that we all hope to find. Great job Belmar - we'll be back the next time we're in the area!

I call this place my fat pill factory. Oh my god! The cookies are great. The pies are even better.

Was not exited when my eleven year old wanted a chocolate cake with chocolate icing, just not not my favorite. But the was rich and delicious, one my all time favorites. The screen print looked great, we will definitely be back.

Called for a dark sweet cherry pie. Not even willing to do it. "We just have this kind". Thank you Scratch Made for always accommodating and working so well with your customers. Belmar is closer for me but Scratch Made is worth the drive across town for super friendly, helpful staff and always super delicious products. Signed - no longer a Belmar Bakery customer.

I had lunch at Belmar today after not eaten there in over 2 years. My spinach quiche had a fishy taste...weird. The cheese jalapeno soup was thin and watery. The key lime pie was tan in color and the crust was mushy and soggy. Tasteless pie. Last but not least the chocolate chip cookie on the plate was tasteless and I think it was old or pulled out of freezer, thawed and served. What happened? Two years ago the food was a lot better...

Went there for chocolate ribbon cookies and cinnamon rolls this morning. Got home to find both are clearly not from today. Closed Sunday so they have to be from Saturday (two day olds). Called to talked to a manager and got the owner who told me to “shove them up my a$$”. Been going there for well over twenty years and sad to hear that.